Jose Raul Capablanca vs Frank Marshall
Manhattan Chess Club, 1918 · result 1-0 · source: chess1/Stockfish 18 (depth 12)
Opening: Ruy Lopez: Marshall Attack — this game followed that line's move order.
Jose Raul Capablanca faced Frank Marshall in Manhattan Chess Club, 1918. Jose Raul Capablanca won. The game lasted 36 moves. The opening was the Ruy Lopez: Marshall Attack.
Both players castled kingside: White on move 5, Black on move 7. The first capture came on move 9.
Alternative: The open game is the stage: e5 measures +0.4 against e6's +0.3. Whatever Marshall prepared, it started from this classical handshake. Best was e6.
Alternative: Bb5 ties the bishop to the knight plan; d4 was the level alternative, +0.4 either way. The Ruy Lopez is chosen, and with it the whole 1918 script. Best was d4.
Alternative: Be7 declines the central grab — Nxe4 kept the balance at +0.4 — and settles into the main tabiya. Marshall has his novelty ready; the board does not know yet. Best was Nxe4.
Brilliancy: Nxe5!! takes the centre pawn knowing the knight will pay for it — the engine already prefers White at +0.8. This is the front door of the whole gambit: material is a detail, the initiative is the argument.
Excellent: Rxe5! is forced and exact: Qh5 already folds into -3.3, while the recapture keeps the extra pawn at +0.5. The whole debate of the opening lives inside this single capture. Best was Qh5.
Brilliancy: Bg4!! is Marshall's own piece on the altar — the engine gives +1.1 to White, and the board gets sharper anyway. The compensation is real: the queen pinned to the rook, the dark-squared bishop swinging to h2, and a white king about to become the most travelled piece on the board.
Inaccuracy: Qh3?! lets a shade of the advantage go: from +1.7 to +0.8. A rare moment where the champion's hand visibly wavers.
Excellent: Kd3! is the move that made the game immortal — the king walks into the open board with total calm, and there is nothing else: Be3 already collapses to -3.3. From the third rank the king stops being a target and starts being a piece. Best was Be3.
Inaccuracy: c5?! gives the queenside its final shape at the wrong angle: from +2.1 the evaluation edges to +2.8. Every pawn exchange from here favours the better-placed king.
Inaccuracy: Bb4?! steps the bishop onto a square it will regret: from +2.8 the game slides to +3.6. In endings, the piece that has to keep moving is usually the losing one.
Inaccuracy: h6?! is the kind of move that fills a score sheet without changing anything that matters: from +4.1 the number drifts to +4.7. The white b-pawn is suddenly the fastest runner in the ending.
Inaccuracy: Re3?! is the last active try: from +4.6 the number jumps to +5.8, and the rook abandons the eighth rank exactly when it matters most. The final check arrives two moves later, with the b-pawn one square from queening.
Key moments
Alternative e5
The open game is the stage: e5 measures +0.4 against e6's +0.3. Whatever Marshall prepared, it started from this classical handshake. Best was e6.
Alternative Bb5
Bb5 ties the bishop to the knight plan; d4 was the level alternative, +0.4 either way. The Ruy Lopez is chosen, and with it the whole 1918 script. Best was d4.
Alternative Be7
Be7 declines the central grab — Nxe4 kept the balance at +0.4 — and settles into the main tabiya. Marshall has his novelty ready; the board does not know yet. Best was Nxe4.
Brilliancy Nxe5
Nxe5!! takes the centre pawn knowing the knight will pay for it — the engine already prefers White at +0.8. This is the front door of the whole gambit: material is a detail, the initiative is the argument. It captures the pawn on e5.
Excellent Rxe5
Rxe5! is forced and exact: Qh5 already folds into -3.3, while the recapture keeps the extra pawn at +0.5. The whole debate of the opening lives inside this single capture. It captures the knight on e5. Best was Qh5.
Brilliancy Bg4
Bg4!! is Marshall's own piece on the altar — the engine gives +1.1 to White, and the board gets sharper anyway. The compensation is real: the queen pinned to the rook, the dark-squared bishop swinging to h2, and a white king about to become the most travelled piece on the board.
Inaccuracy Qh3
Qh3?! lets a shade of the advantage go: from +1.7 to +0.8. A rare moment where the champion's hand visibly wavers.
Excellent Kd3
Kd3! is the move that made the game immortal — the king walks into the open board with total calm, and there is nothing else: Be3 already collapses to -3.3. From the third rank the king stops being a target and starts being a piece. Best was Be3.
Inaccuracy c5
c5?! gives the queenside its final shape at the wrong angle: from +2.1 the evaluation edges to +2.8. Every pawn exchange from here favours the better-placed king.
Inaccuracy Bb4
Bb4?! steps the bishop onto a square it will regret: from +2.8 the game slides to +3.6. In endings, the piece that has to keep moving is usually the losing one.
Inaccuracy h6
h6?! is the kind of move that fills a score sheet without changing anything that matters: from +4.1 the number drifts to +4.7. The white b-pawn is suddenly the fastest runner in the ending.
Inaccuracy Re3
Re3?! is the last active try: from +4.6 the number jumps to +5.8, and the rook abandons the eighth rank exactly when it matters most. The final check arrives two moves later, with the b-pawn one square from queening.
More classic games
- Garry Kasparov vs Veselin Topalov (1999, 1-0) — 44 moves
- Robert James Fischer vs Boris Spassky (1972, 1-0) — 41 moves
- Bent Larsen vs Robert James Fischer (1967, 0-1) — 61 moves
- Robert James Fischer vs Leonid Stein (1967, 1-0) — 56 moves